European Review logo

ISSUE 65 page 2

Click for country articles

Choose a country to take your mouse,clicking on most will show an article on that country

Temporary and agency workers multiplying as regulation proves difficult
THE RISE OF THE TEMPORARY AGENCY WORKER shows no sign of tapering off as the labour market in most EU Member States remains in the doldrums, however the experiences of different countries vary as much as their economic prospects. A recent survey by the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions (Eurofound) found that the percentage of workers in temporary employment has increased since the onset of the crisis in 2008 in 19 of the 27 nations. In Spain and Poland, where previously there was a high proportion of temps, their prevalence has declined, though for opposite reasons. The Polish boom saw companies absorbing temporary workers by giving them permanent positions while the huge drop in employment in Spain fell disproportionately on temps who were easier to lay off than their permanent colleagues. Three countries where temporary employment has recently increased have all experienced problems in its regulation. In Germany trade unions have won the right to veto any attempt by an employer to recruit workers from an agency if there is no time limit on their contract. The IG Metall and Ver.di unions want the courts to go further and clarify just how long a job can last before it ceases to count as ‘temporary’. The Netherlands faces ‘revolving door’ practices whereby a temporary employee is terminated just before reaching three years in post after which companies are legally bound to offer a permanent contract. The worker is then laid off for at least three months, so that their consecutive record of employment is broken, and then re-hired as a temp.

O'Grady, F.

Following the conclusion of a ‘social agreement’ between the social partners (see issue 62) the Minister of Social Affairs intends to close these loopholes by reducing the maximum length of temporary contracts from three to two years, increasing the ‘break’ period to six months and abolishing zero-hours contracts. The latter are becoming an increasing bone of contention in the U.K. but here employers are making growing use of another way of circumventing the 2008 EU Temporary Agency Workers Directive. The so-called ‘Swedish derogation’ allows agencies not to pay those they directly employ the same rate as permanent staff doing the same job as long as they continue paying for at least four weeks when staff are between assignments. In Sweden this results merely in a 90% salary when looking for work but in Britain some agencies pay temps up to £135 a week less than colleagues in the same workplace and halve even this rate after they finish. According to the TUC a report for employment agencies recently estimated that one in six of their workers are on these contracts. The union federation has made an official complaint to the European Commission that the British government has not fully implemented the EU directive. General secretary Frances O'Grady said: ‘The recent agency worker regulations have improved working conditions for many agency workers without causing job losses. However, the regulations are being undermined by a growing number of employers who are putting staff on contracts that deny them equal pay’.

Frances O’Grady



Bargaining round-up

THE HEALTHCARE SYSTEM IN ROMANIA WAS RANKED THE WORST OF 33 countries surveyed by the European Healthcare Consumer Index in 2010. 10,000 doctors and nurses, who recently marched through Bucharest, believe that government spending must be increased to remedy this as, currently, only 4.3 % of GDP is disbursed, less than half the EU average. This amounts to €700 per citizen compared to €4,000 in countries such as the Netherlands and Austria. As well as increasing general spending to 6% of GDP the protesters want higher salaries and better working conditions. At the moment a qualified doctor earns about €1,500 per month leading to an exodus to western Europe so that there are now only 1.95 doctors per 1,000 people in Romania compared to an average in the EU of 3.18.
A LAST MINUTE DEAL AT NORWEGIAN AIR HAS HEADED OFF A STRIKE over wages and pensions. Pilots’ union Parat managed to retain their pay and benefits agreement and the percentage of salary which forms a pension on retirement. However some questions of principle including employment by subsidiaries were conceded. The dispute was exacerbated when Norwegian media published wage rates for newly-recruited Thai cabin staff that showed a monthly salary of the equivalent of $500, much less than Norwegian staff get. ‘I don’t see any reason at all to fly on Norwegian when it behaves in this manner’ commented Stein Gulbrandsen, head of Norway’s largest labour organisation.
TRADE UNIONS AND MANAGEMENT IN THE LUXEMBOURG BANKING SECTOR have come to an agreement on harassment which puts flesh on the bones of the national deal signed in 2009. It covers the employer’s duty to prevent harassment and the internal procedures which should be followed when an allegation is made. Companies must adopt a declaration of principle that harassment will not be tolerated in their establishment, raise awareness of the ‘definition of moral harassment, the ways in which it is to be dealt with in the company and the penalties which may be imposed’ and provide training on prevention and protection. The internal procedures must lay down how to deal with a complaint in a discreet and confidential way, who is to have authority to receive the complaint, a time limit for dealing with it and the kind of support and external assistance available to the victim. The latter can be from a psychologist and/or the Association for Occupational Health in the Financial Sector (ASTF). The social partners expressed satisfaction with the deal although Marc Glesener, President of one of the signatory unions, ALEBA, called it a response to the increase in work-related stress which is linked to restructuring within the financial sector.

Top of page




LiechtensteinMoldovaMacedoniaAlbaniaBulgariaRomaniaLithuaniaLuxembourgLatviaSlovakiaUkraineHungaryMaltaEstoniaFinlandNetherlandsDenmarkFranceAustriaCzech RepublicGreeceItalyPolandGermanyBelgiumSpainPortugalSwedenIrelandSloveniaNorwayTurkeyRussiaIcelandSwitzerlandCroatia